Skip to content
CompanyBenchCompanyBench

T4 employee vs incorporated IT contractor: a buyer's guide for Canada

T4 employee, incorporated IT contractor or a firm: how the CRA decides status, what a personal services business is, and what a buyer has to report.

A Canadian company can bring in an IT contractor three ways: as a T4 employee on its own payroll, as an incorporated contractor billing through a personal corporation, or through a firm such as CompanyBench, where the consultant stays employed by their own IT company. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) decides status from how the work really runs, not from the label in the agreement.

Most pages on "T4 vs incorporated" are written for contractors choosing which offer to accept. This one is for the buyer: what the CRA looks at, where the personal services business rules bite, what you have to report when you pay a contractor's corporation, and when to call your accountant. It summarises CRA publications checked in November 2026; it is not tax or legal advice.

Three ways to engage an IT contractor

T4 employee (fixed term or permanent)Incorporated contractorThrough a firm (CompanyBench)
Who the person works forYouTheir own corporation, which contracts with youTheir own employer, an IT vendor; the vendor contracts with CompanyBench, which contracts with you
Payroll and source deductionsYou deduct CPP, EI and income tax and issue a T4The corporation handles its own; you pay its invoicesThe vendor handles its own; you pay CompanyBench's monthly invoice
Who carries the status questionNone: they are your employeeYou and the contractor, if the CRA finds the relationship is employmentThe consultant is the vendor's employee, not a self-employed individual working for you
Personal services business riskNot applicableSits with the contractor's corporationNot a personal corporation you are paying
Your year-end reportingT4 slipsFees for services, T4A box 048, when payments pass the thresholdAsk your accountant; the entity you pay is a firm, not an individual
Benefits, vacation, severanceYours under employment standardsNone from youNone from you
Typical useCore roles you want on staffA specialist running their own consulting businessSkills you need for months, offshore by default, without managing the vendor

What qualifies someone as an independent contractor?

For contracts formed outside Quebec the CRA takes two steps. First, what did the parties intend: a contract of service (employment) or a contract for services (a business relationship)? Second, do the real working conditions match that intent? For the second step it weighs:

  • Control: how far the payer directs methods, hours and activities, or has the right to.
  • Tools and equipment: who supplies and pays for them.
  • Subcontracting or hiring helpers: whether the worker can send someone else or take on assistants.
  • Financial risk: fixed costs, unreimbursed expenses and liability the worker carries.
  • Investment and management: whether the worker puts in capital and makes business decisions.
  • Opportunity for profit: whether the worker can make a profit or a loss, rather than a fixed return for time.
  • Anything else relevant, such as the written agreement.

Intent on its own decides nothing. Calling someone a contractor in the paperwork does not make them one if they work like staff.

Contracts formed in Quebec

For a contract formed in Quebec the CRA uses three steps based on the Civil Code of Québec: establish the parties' intention; test the relationship against the Code's definitions of a contract of employment and a contract for services, using three factors (carrying out the work, remuneration and subordination); then compare the intention with how the work actually runs. The CRA says subordination helps distinguish an employer-employee relationship from a business one. Montreal buyers should also check Revenu Québec's position with an adviser.

What the CRA says about IT consultants

The CRA publishes guidance written for IT work. Some facts are neutral when the job itself requires them: a secure site, set schedules, the client's equipment. Because experienced consultants need little direction, the question is whether the payer has control or the right to control, whether or not it uses it.

Points toward employeePoints toward self-employed
The payer can redirect the consultant and hand out new tasks or prioritiesAn identifiable project; the consultant is not normally reassigned
The payer sets methods and requires approval for certain actionsThe consultant agrees to deliver a given result
The payer controls location and hoursThe consultant bears the cost of rework or penalties and carries own insurance
Exclusive service, integral to the payer's businessNegotiates rates, can turn down projects, holds several defined mandates
Paid vacation, sick days, pension or expense reimbursementA business presence: own invoices, advertising, licence, separate bank account, sales tax registration

Two further points from the same guidance. A worker cannot be both an employee and self-employed under one agreement. And when a consultant works through their own corporation, the client is not normally seen as the employer: the CRA says the consultant is usually an employee of that corporation. That is exactly where the personal services business rules come in.

Personal services business: the incorporated contractor's risk

A personal services business (PSB) is the CRA's term for a corporation providing services where, without the corporation, the worker would be the client's employee. People call the worker an incorporated employee. All five CRA conditions must be met:

  1. The worker provides their services through a corporation.
  2. The worker, or a related person, is a specified shareholder: owns at least 10% of the issued shares at any time in the year.
  3. The corporation employs 5 full-time employees or fewer in the business throughout the year.
  4. The payments don't come from a corporation associated with the worker's corporation.
  5. The worker would reasonably be considered the payer's employee if the corporation did not exist.

The consequences land on the contractor's corporation. The CRA's fact sheet says a PSB pays full federal and provincial corporate rates plus an additional 5% tax on PSB income, can't claim the small business deduction or the general rate reduction, and can't deduct the same expenses as other corporations.

Why the buyer should care: an incorporated contractor with one client, your hours, your laptop and your manager looks a lot like an employee. A contractor who learns of the risk mid-project can ask to renegotiate or walk away, and if the CRA finds an individual is really your employee, CPP contributions and EI premiums are an employer's obligation.

Do you need to issue a T4A to a contractor's corporation?

The CRA's reporting-fees-for-services rules say a business must report fees it pays to other businesses for services when the total passes 500 Canadian dollars in a calendar year, reported on a T4A slip with the amount in box 048. Plenty of payroll guides say payments to corporations are exempt; the CRA's own fact sheet does not say that, so confirm your filing position with your accountant rather than a blog.

If the person you pay is outside Canada and not registered for GST/HST, a second rule can apply: the CRA says you may have to self-assess GST or the federal part of HST on imported services used less than 90% in commercial activities, or file Form GST59 if you are not registered.

Contracting through a firm such as CompanyBench

With CompanyBench the consultant is a salaried employee of an IT vendor, based in India for most Canadian work. The vendor signs with CompanyBench and CompanyBench signs a matching back-to-back agreement with you. You are not engaging an individual or their personal corporation.

  • One party to pay. An agreed hourly or monthly rate for approved timesheets, one invoice a month. CompanyBench pays the vendor.
  • The employer stays the employer. Salary, leave and employer obligations are the vendor's.
  • You still direct the daily work. That is the point of staff augmentation, and the reason this model differs from a self-employed contractor meant to work independently.
  • Cross-border tax is still a question. CompanyBench has not set its contracting entity, invoice currency or tax treatment for Canada yet, so take the draft agreement to your accountant.

Example: replacing a long-running incorporated contractor

Example: a Toronto insurer has used one incorporated Java developer full time for two years, on its laptops, at its hours, reporting to its team lead, with no other clients. Its accountant flags the pattern against the CRA's control factors. The company decides to move the work to a firm.

It writes a requirement: Java and Spring Boot, the policy-admin integrations, overlap 9 a.m. to 12 p.m. Eastern, twelve months, remote.

CompanyBench sends at least 3 masked profiles within 48 hours; the team lead interviews two on a live code review of an existing service, picks one, and plans a four-week hand-over from the outgoing contractor before the start.

When to ask the CRA for a ruling, or an accountant

If either side is unsure of status, the payer or the worker can ask the CRA for a CPP/EI ruling online through the CRA's business or personal accounts, or with Form CPT1 by mail. The CRA says the request is due by June 29 of the year after the year in question. Talk to an accountant or tax lawyer before you sign when:

  • You are about to engage an incorporated contractor full time, long term, as their only client.
  • A former employee wants to come back incorporated, doing the same job.
  • The contract will be formed in Quebec.
  • You are paying for services delivered from outside Canada.
  • A contractor asks to switch to a T4 partway through, or the reverse.
  • The CRA has asked you about a worker's status.

Comparing delivery models rather than tax status? See contract IT consultants by technology, or go back to the CompanyBench Canada home.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a T4 employee and an incorporated contractor?

A T4 employee is on your payroll: you deduct CPP, EI and income tax and issue a T4. An incorporated contractor bills you through their own corporation, which pays its own taxes. The CRA decides which the relationship really is from the facts, such as control, tools, financial risk and opportunity for profit, not the agreement's title.

What qualifies you as an independent contractor in Canada?

The CRA looks first at what the parties intended, then at whether the work matches it: who controls methods and hours, who supplies tools, whether the worker can subcontract, carries financial risk, invests and can make a profit or loss. In Quebec, the CRA applies the Civil Code test, where subordination is one of three factors.

What is a personal services business?

It is a corporation whose worker would be the client's employee if the corporation did not exist, where the worker or a related person owns at least 10% of the shares and the corporation has 5 full-time employees or fewer. The CRA says a PSB pays full corporate rates plus an additional 5% tax and loses the small business deduction.

Do I need to issue a T4A for a subcontractor?

Possibly. The CRA says businesses must report fees paid to other businesses for services once the year's total passes 500 Canadian dollars, in box 048 of a T4A slip. Many guides claim corporations are exempt, but the CRA fact sheet doesn't say so. Check your position with your accountant.

Can a Canadian company hire a foreign independent contractor?

Yes. Status still turns on the same CRA factors, and there is a sales-tax point: the CRA says a business buying services from an unregistered non-resident may need to self-assess GST/HST when it uses them less than 90% in commercial activities. Ask your accountant before the first invoice.

Is contracting through CompanyBench the same as hiring an incorporated contractor?

No. The consultant is employed by their own company, an IT vendor, which contracts with CompanyBench. You contract with CompanyBench and pay one monthly invoice. You are not engaging an individual or a personal corporation, and the consultant never joins your payroll.

How do I get a CRA ruling on a worker's status?

The payer or the worker can request a CPP/EI ruling through the CRA's online accounts, or send Form CPT1 to the CRA by mail. The CRA says the request is due by June 29 of the year after the year the question relates to.

Tell us what you need

A vetted shortlist within 48 hours of confirming the requirement. No fees until someone starts.

What you need
How to reach you

We use these details only to respond to you. See our privacy policy.

Sources

Last reviewed November 22, 2026.

Our Canada office

88 Queens Quay W, Suite 2500, Toronto ON M5J 0B6, Canada